| Monster | Drop chance |
|---|---|
| Bloodraven (Nightmare) | 23.33333% |
| Nihlathak (Nightmare) | 23.33333% |
| The Feature Creep (Nightmare) | 23.33333% |
| izual (Nightmare) | 23.33333% |
| Radament (Nightmare) | 16.41791% |
| Andariel (Nightmare) | 16.41791% |
| Council Member (Nightmare) | 16.36364% |
| Council Member (Nightmare) | 16.36364% |
| Council Member (Nightmare) | 16.36364% |
| Summoner (Nightmare) | 16.36364% |
| Duriel (Nightmare) | 8.20896% |
| Baal Crab (Nightmare) | 6.25000% |
| Diablo (Nightmare) | 6.25000% |
| Mephisto (Nightmare) | 6.25000% |